1900 Windsor Spec Study
Spec study for RESICAP

1900 Windsor Drive SW

A live Atlanta listing, specced from its photos and priced against renovated sales within a mile. Prepared after my call with your team about the Fix & Flip Designer role.

1956 brick ranch · 3 bed / 2 bath · 1,350 sf · walk-out basement · listed as-is at $115,000

Purchase
$105,000
Back on market after a July contract fell through
Rehab
$117,418
Includes 10% contingency
Resale
$296,400
$190 per sf plus the basement
Net profit
$40,945
16.0% on total cost
Rendering of 1900 Windsor with painted trim, a new front door, copper lanterns and new plantingConcept rendering
01 · The spec

Keep what buyers won’t pay to replace.

Renovated sales nearby show painted cabinets, stone counters, stainless and hard floors. This spec meets that level and stops there. Drag the handle to compare.

Listing photoRendering

Room costs exclude the 10% contingency.

Where the $117,418 goes

Direct costs by area, before contingency.

$106,744 direct + $10,674 contingency$117,418

10 Kept

Brick and roof lineWood windowsConcrete stoopOak floorsStained trimPine panelingKitchen cabinets and layoutBlue bath tile, tub and sinkMint tilePorch screen frames

6 Replaced

GuttersCounters and appliancesKitchen and dining floorToilets and one vanityLighting and hardwareHeat pump, ducts, panel, supply lines

4 Upgraded

Half-glass front doorCopper lanternsPlanting beds and sodFinished basement

The renderings show copper gutters, a wood stoop and a cedar porch wall. The budget uses copper-tone aluminum gutters, keeps the concrete stoop with new rails, and re-screens the existing porch frames.

02 · Comps

Six renovated sales within a mile.

Sold in the last 12 months, 1,000 to 1,700 sf, built 1946 to 1966, lots under half an acre. Uncheck a sale to see how the average moves.

IncludeAddressSoldSfBuiltLot (ac)MilesBathsPriceBath adj.Per sf
Average of checked sales, bath-adjusted
$200.65
Underwriting rate (set in Numbers)
$190
Cushion below the average
5.3%

Sales short a bath are adjusted up $10,000 per full bath and $5,000 per half. 1689 Laurelwood sold off-MLS after a 2023 renovation.

Left out: 2541 Headland and 1883 Windsor (lots over half an acre) and 2665 Ivydale Ct (built 1990).

03 · Basement

700 finished feet for $21,913.

Each dollar spent here returns $1.82 at resale. A walk-out with windows and heat and air supports a 30% credit on the main-floor rate.

Example rendering of the unfinished basement: open joists, block walls, furnace, water heater and a walk-out door Rendering of the finished basement with a wood plank ceiling, bookcase wall and stained concrete floor Before, example renderingAfter, rendering
Adds at resale
$39,900
Costs to build
$21,913
Net gain
$14,955
30%
0%Breaks even at 18%50%

The listing has no photo of the unfinished basement, so the before image is an example rendering. Appraisers report below-grade space on its own line (ANSI Z765). 2350 Manor Ave, a 1956 ranch with a finished basement 0.98 miles away, sold $71,950 above its main floor at $190 a foot.

What it costs

Wood-look MDF plank ceiling$3,500
Bookcase wall with rolling ladder$1,540
Ground and stained concrete floor$2,625
Painted block, mechanical closet, louvered doors$4,286
Lighting, outlets, heat and air$3,870
Prep, sealing, dehumidifier, stairs, doors, permits$4,100
With 10% contingency$21,913

$31 per finished sf. Prime every MDF cut edge, and hang the planks after the dehumidifier is running.

04 · Numbers

Move the inputs. The deal updates.

Cash purchase, 7.6% selling costs plus $4,700 in fixed closing and staging costs.

$105,000
$190
30%
0%
3
Net profit
$40,945
Clears the $30,000 minimum
Resale$296,400
Rehab with contingency$117,418
Total cost$255,455
Return on total cost16.0%
Highest price for a $30,000 profit$115,945

If it goes sideways

Each line starts from the inputs above.

Rehab runs 15% over$23,333
Sale lands 5% under$27,252
Hold runs three months longer$38,135
Appraiser gives the basement nothing$4,078
05 · Before closing

Five things a finish schedule would miss.

1

Leave the old tile in place.

The 1956 tile and black glue may contain asbestos. The new checkerboard floor floats over it and saves $2,800 of removal.

2

Time the listing for FHA buyers.

FHA buyers can’t sign until we’ve owned the house 90 days. List around day 75 and keep receipts for a second appraisal.

3

Fix all peeling paint.

FHA and VA appraisers flag it on pre-1978 homes. Trim, windows and the porch ceiling get scraped and painted lead-safe.

4

Test before closing.

$1,400 of sewer, asbestos, radon and termite checks shows how much of the $24,750 systems budget we’ll spend.

5

Ask why the last contract died.

Sold for $210,000 in 2022 and $193,315 in 2025. Under contract in July, back on the market in October.

06 · About me

A licensed agent in the designer’s seat.

Licensed Realtor and interior designer in Lafayette, Louisiana since 2022. I represent buyers and sellers, advise investors and landlords, and flip houses of my own.

Finishes priced the way buyers pay.

I pull renovated sales for every client and every flip. A finish goes in when sold listings show buyers pay for it.

Specs built to pass the appraisal.

I negotiate inspections, repairs and appraisals for buyers and sellers. What lenders flag gets fixed in the base budget.

Ready to buy and sell in Georgia.

Georgia licenses Louisiana agents by reciprocity: no exam, under $500, active in weeks. That opens GAMLS and FMLS for comps, offers and listings.

Licensed Realtor®Interior designerBuyers and sellersInvestor clientsRestoration flipsLiDAR site scans

I’d start with the role as posted: catalog selections for two to three properties a day. Within 60 days, I’ll deliver a spec package for one submarket.

Shelby Youtsas
(337) 849-3995
Listing photos: Georgia MLS #10793428, courtesy of Solutions First Realty LLC. Renderings are concepts; the basement before image is an example. Costs are planning allowances, not bids.