315 N. Demanade Boulevard
Lafayette, Louisiana 70503
Keep It, Sell It, or SPY It
A paid-off house vs the S&P 500 · Shelby Youtsas
Dial the Assumptions
โ
Annual NOI
โ
Cap Rate
โ
Total Return on Equity
โ
Monthly Cash Flow
Three Paths on the New House
A โ Sell & Roll (Low Note)
Down (all proceeds in)โ
Loanโ
P&I noteโ
Income offsetโ
Net monthlyโ
Equity earns0%
B โ Sell: Half S&P, Half Down
Down (half proceeds, after costs)โ
Loanโ
P&I noteโ
S&P draw (4% rule)โ
Net monthlyโ
Equity earnsโ
Income shown is a 4% sustainable withdrawal so the portfolio keeps compounding. Spending the full average return each month means selling shares and giving up the growth this whole comparison is built on.
C โ Keep as Rental (The Pitch)
Down (from savings)โ
Loanโ
P&I noteโ
Tenant coversโ
Net monthlyโ
Equity earnsโ
The Equity Duel โ 10-Year Race
Sell โ S&P 500 (net of 7% selling costs)
Keep the house (value + rents reinvested)
โ
Rental path = house value appreciating + NOI reinvested at the S&P rate. Pre-tax on both sides โ see The Tax Angle below for why the sides aren't taxed the same. Educational comparison, not investment or tax advice.
The Tax Angle (Read This Part)
- Selling now is tax-free. Because y'all lived in the house 2 of the last 5 years, up to $500k of gain (married filing jointly) is excluded under Section 121. The check at closing is the only fully tax-free money anywhere in this comparison.
- That tax-free window doesn't slam shut when you move. It survives roughly 3 more years after move-out. Translation: you can rent the house for 2โ3 years, find out whether you actually like being landlords, and still sell tax-free if you don't. Renting is reversible. Selling is not. That option is worth real money and it never shows up on the chart.
- The S&P path is not tax-free going forward. Dividends are taxed every year and gains are taxed when you sell. The red line above is a pre-tax line.
- The rental path has a tax shield, with a catch. Depreciation shelters a chunk of the rental income each year. The catch: if you keep it past the ~3-year window and sell later, the gain becomes taxable and the IRS recaptures that depreciation at up to 25% โ though a 1031 exchange can keep deferring it.
- Louisiana landlord reality. The day it converts to a rental, the homestead exemption goes away (property taxes step up) and the homeowner policy becomes a landlord policy. Both are already baked into the taxes + insurance number above โ that's why it looks high.
I'm your Realtor, not your CPA โ before pulling the trigger on any of these paths, run the tax side past a CPA. I'll happily join that call.